Fit statistics

Introduction

This page describes the fit statistics used in gammapy. These fit statistics are used by datasets to perform model fitting and parameter estimation.

Fit statistics in gammapy are all log-likelihood functions normalized like chi-squares, i.e. if \(L\) is the likelihood function used, they follow the expression \(2 \times log L\).

All functions compute per-bin statistics. If you want the summed statistics for all bins, call sum on the output array yourself.

Cash : Poisson data with background model

The number of counts, \(n\), is a Poisson random variable of mean value \(\mu_{\mathrm{sig}} + \mu_{\mathrm{bkg}}\). The former is the expected number of counts from the source (the signal), the latter is the number of expected background counts, which is supposed to be known. We can write the likelihood \(L\) and applying the expression above, we obtain the following formula for the Cash fit statistic:

\[C = 2 \times \left(\mu_{\mathrm{sig}} + \mu_{\mathrm{bkg}} - n \times log (\mu_{\mathrm{sig}} + \mu_{\mathrm{bkg}}) \right)\]

The Cash statistic is implemented in cash and is used as a stat function by the MapDataset and the SpectrumDataset.

Example

Here’s an example for the cash statistic:

>>> from gammapy.stats import cash
>>> data = [3, 5, 9]
>>> model = [3.3, 6.8, 9.2]
>>> cash(data, model)
array([ -0.56353481,  -5.56922612, -21.54566271])
>>> cash(data, model).sum()
-27.678423645645118

WStat : Poisson data with background measurement

In the absence of a reliable background model, it is possible to use a second measurement containing only background to estimate it.

In the OFF region, which contains background only, the number of counts \(n_{\mathrm{off}}\) is a Poisson random variable of mean value \(\alpha,\mu_{\mathrm{bkg}}\) In the ON region which contains signal and background contribution, the number of counts, \(n_{\mathrm{on}}\), is a Poisson random variable of mean value \(\mu_{\mathrm{sig}} + \mu_{\mathrm{bkg}}\), where \(\alpha\) is the ratio of the ON and OFF region acceptances, and \(\mu_{\mathrm{bkg}}\) the mean background counts in the ON region.

It is possible define a likelihood function and marginalize it over the unknown \(\mu_{\mathrm{bkg}}\) to obtain \(\mu_{\mathrm{sig}}\). This yields the so-called WStat or ON-OFF statistics which is traditionally used for ON-OFF measurements in ground based gamma-ray astronomy.

The WStat fit statistics is given by the following formula:

\[W = 2 \big(\mu_{\mathrm{sig}} + (1 + 1/\alpha)\mu_{\mathrm{bkg}} - n_{\mathrm{on}} \log{(\mu_{\mathrm{sig}} + \mu_{\mathrm{bkg}})} - n_{\mathrm{off}} \log{(\mu_{\mathrm{bkg}}/\alpha)}\big)\]

To see how to derive it see the wstat derivation.

The WStat statistic is implemented in wstat and is used as a stat function by the MapDatasetOnOff and the SpectrumDatasetOnOff.

Caveat

  • Since WStat takes into account background estimation uncertainties and makes no assumption such as a background model, it usually gives larger statistical uncertainties on the fitted parameters. If a background model exists, to properly compare with parameters estimated using the Cash statistics, one should include some systematic uncertainty on the background model.

  • Note also that at very low counts, WStat is known to result in biased estimates. This can be an issue when studying the high energy behaviour of faint sources. When performing spectral fits with WStat, it is recommended to randomize observations and check whether the resulting fitted parameters distributions are consistent with the input values.

Example

The following table gives an overview over values that WStat takes in different scenarios

>>> from gammapy.stats import wstat
>>> from astropy.table import Table
>>> table = Table()
>>> table['mu_sig'] = [0.1, 0.1, 1.4, 0.2, 0.1, 5.2, 6.2, 4.1, 6.4, 4.9, 10.2,
...                    16.9, 102.5]
>>> table['n_on'] = [0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 5, 5, 5, 5, 5, 10, 20, 100]
>>> table['n_off'] = [0, 1, 1, 10 , 10, 0, 5, 5, 20, 40, 2, 70, 10]
>>> table['alpha'] = [0.01, 0.01, 0.5, 0.1 , 0.2, 0.2, 0.2, 0.01, 0.4, 0.4,
...                   0.2, 0.1, 0.6]
>>> table['wstat'] = wstat(n_on=table['n_on'],
...                        n_off=table['n_off'],
...                        alpha=table['alpha'],
...                        mu_sig=table['mu_sig'])
>>> table['wstat'].format = '.3f'
>>> table.pprint()
mu_sig n_on n_off alpha wstat
------ ---- ----- ----- ------
   0.1    0     0  0.01  0.200
   0.1    0     1  0.01  0.220
   1.4    0     1   0.5  3.611
   0.2    0    10   0.1  2.306
   0.1    0    10   0.2  3.846
   5.2    5     0   0.2  0.008
   6.2    5     5   0.2  0.736
   4.1    5     5  0.01  0.163
   6.4    5    20   0.4  7.125
   4.9    5    40   0.4 14.578
  10.2   10     2   0.2  0.034
  16.9   20    70   0.1  0.656
 102.5  100    10   0.6  0.663

Notes

All above formulae are equivalent to what is given on the XSpec manual statistics page with the substitutions:

\[\begin{split}\mu_{\mathrm{sig}} = t_s \cdot m_i \\ \mu_{\mathrm{bkg}} = t_b \cdot m_b \\ \alpha = t_s / t_b \\\end{split}\]